By Mary Jo Wagner, freelance writer, Vancouver,
British Columbia, Canada.
Sequels often are viewed with skepticism,
particularly if the first product was highly lauded. This is where MDA
Geospatial Services (www.mdacorporation.com/geospatial)
finds itself as it prepares for the launch of RADARSAT-2, the highly
anticipated follow up to the successful RADARSAT-1 commercial satellite
program. But if industry pundits' predictions are right, when RADARSAT-2
is operational in 2007, users may agree that the sequel can indeed be
better than the first.
Indeed, that would be a fortuitous consensus for Richmond, British
Columbia-based MacDonald, Dettwiler and Associates Ltd. (MDA), owner and
operator of RADARSAT-2. By successfully building a healthy commercial
market for SAR with RADARSAT-1, RADARSAT-2 now will enter a more crowded
SAR space, joining Europe's ENVISAT, Japan's ALOS and Germany's TerraSAR-X.
And all of these SAR satellites have overlapping capabilities and are
suitable for a range of similar applications.
But according to Dr. Vernon Singhroy, a professional engineer and senior
research scientist at the Canada Centre for Remote Sensing (CCRS), there
are some overriding distinctions that set RADARSAT-2 apart from other
SAR satellites. "Advanced sensor capabilities are one aspect, but
the distribution capabilities are another," he says from CCRS'
headquarters in Ottawa. "RADARSAT-2 will already have the infrastructure
to provide users with reliable and rapid data delivery. Having both
aspects from the start puts RADARSAT-2 in a unique market position."
Many Means to an End
Departing from the original government-led RADARSAT-1 program, the
RADARSAT-2 mission represents a public-private partnership between MDA
and the Canadian Space Agency (CSA). MDA will own and operate the
satellite and ground segment—MDA's Geospatial Services will still direct
and manage the commercial distribution of the data—and CSA has
contributed funds for the satellite's construction and launch. In
exchange for its financial investment in the program, CSA will receive
RADARSAT-2 data for Canadian government agencies during the lifetime of
the mission.
As owner and operator of RADARSAT-2, MDA wanted to ensure the sequel
wouldn't disappoint. The company chose a trusted trio of companies to
build the satellite's three main components: the SAR payload, the Bus
and the Extendible Support Structure (ESS).
The ESS is the mechanical interface between the Bus and Antenna
structure that deploys the radar antenna and maintains it in a stable,
precise position for accurate imaging. EMS Technologies Canada in
Montreal (now MDA) was the primary contractor for the SAR payload.
Rome-based Alcatel Alenia Space (www1.alcatel-lucent.com/space)
took care of the Bus and ATK-Able (www.aec-able.com) of Santa Barbara,
Calif., was responsible for the ESS. Currently, the spacecraft sits at
the David Florida Laboratory in Ottawa undergoing extensive final tests
before being transported to Kazakhstan where Starsem, the French-Russian
launch company, will manage RADARSAT-2's take off on a Soyuz vehicle
from Kazakhstan's Baikonur Cosmodrome.
Combining Heritage and Innovation
RADARSAT-2 will have many of the same capabilities of its predecessor
and will continue to offer all of RADARSAT-1's beam modes and products,
providing users with data continuity and a seamless transition to
RADARSAT‑2. Moreover, capitalizing on its successes with RADARSAT-1 and
extensive knowledge of user needs and future desires, MDA engineered
RADARSAT-2 to offer several enhanced technical advancements, including
3-meter imaging, fully selectable multipolarization modes, left- and
right-looking imaging options to improve revisit times, superior SAR
imaging time and data storage, and significantly improved programming
lead times and order processing speeds.
One of the hallmarks of the RADARSAT program has been its flexible
imaging modes and the ability for users to select the right beam
combination for their application. RADARSAT-2 will offer this same
flexibility for all beam modes, including the new Ultra-Fine beam mode
(3-meter resolution) and a new Multi-Look Fine mode (8-meter resolution)
that will reduce the speckle noise inherent in the existing Fine mode
and improve users' abilities to discriminate features.
In addition, during the last year, MDA successfully configured the
satellite to accommodate another new beam mode called Spotlight, which
will offer 1-meter nominal resolution with a scene size of approximately
18 kilometers by 8 kilometers. According to Adrian Bohane, MDA
Geospatial Services' director of Worldwide Sales, adding the Spotlight
mode was a strategic decision to further improve its competitive
position in the SAR market.
"It was clear that RADARSAT-2 would be launched in a more competitive
environment and we needed to address that," he says. "Because RADARSAT-2
is completely configurable, it enabled us to develop the Spotlight mode,
which, coupled with our strong ground segment and service delivery,
allows us to greatly improve our commercial offer to traditional and new
markets."
Pole Position
However, when discussing the satellite's features, most researchers,
users and business developers focus on RADARSAT-2's multipolarization, a
capability that enables the SAR sensor to both send and receive
different combinations of polarized waves simultaneously, enabling users
to identify a greater variety of surface features and targets.
Unlike with RADARSAT-1, which is a single co-polarized sensor,
RADARSAT-2 will be able to send out a horizontal wave, but record both
the horizontal and vertical backscatter (HH and HV), or send out a
vertical wave and record both the vertical and horizontal backscatter
(VV and VH). In all, the satellite will be able to record in HH, VV, HV
and VH polarizations simultaneously. With such flexibility, users can
tailor acquisitions to more specifically suit the problem they're trying
to solve. And with the heightened information provided by polarimetric
data, users can eliminate the need to acquire multiple multiangle
RADARSAT-1 scenes.
The trick will be discovering the right combination of polarization to
use. That's a quest that has consumed SAR experts at MDA and captured
the interest of many researchers and users across the globe who have
been conducting research to discover just what fully polarimetric and
selective polarimetric data can offer.
Though they can only make predictions, popular consensus among avid SAR
users and researchers is that the multipolarization and fully
polarimetric (quad-pol) data will be an information boon to a great
number of applications such as maritime surveillance, mapping,
agriculture and defense.
"With RADARSAT-2's selective polarization capabilities, we will acquire
more information content and be able to optimize beam modes to improve
our ability to better discern ships for ship detection applications,"
says Harm Greidanus, a research scientist with the European Commission
(EC) Joint Research Centre (JRC) in Ispra, Italy. "And with the
Ultra-Fine beam and quad-pol data, we expect to improve our capabilities
in classifying ships in ports and in transit."
"If RADARSAT-2 can provide this selective polarization ability and
continues to offer flexible programming and a reliable near real-time
data service, then I think it will be quite attractive for the
maritime-applications market," he adds.
JRC is the primary technology advisor to the EC, so positive support
from the center's researchers could bode well for RADARSAT-2 and MDA's
Geospatial Services as commission members weigh JRC recommendations
heavily when developing new policies. In fact, based on the center's
extensive testing and positive results on the use of SAR imagery for
fisheries control, the EU passed a new fisheries-control regulation on
Dec. 21, 2006. The decree will require all Member States from Jan. 1,
2009, to ensure their fisheries monitoring centers are able to integrate
satellite imagery with vessel monitoring systems, and to routinely use
satellite imagery in scenarios in which the benefits outweigh the costs
to detect fishing vessels in a given area.
An Anchor for Maritime Applications
The broad maritime surveillance sector, including ship detection,
fisheries control, oil spill monitoring, ice monitoring and mapping, has
been a strong market for RADARSAT-1. Its wide-area coverage, adequate
resolution and rapid data delivery has promoted it to a mission-critical
information source for several operational marine monitoring programs,
and most foresee RADARSAT-2 continuing that tradition. For example, the
satellite will be a cornerstone of Canada's $60 million Polar Epsilon
program designed to monitor vessel traffic along Canada's East and West
coasts.
With its enhanced features, the satellite may also
set anchor in new marine sectors such as coastal fisheries and
aquaculture. Hatfield Consultants, an environmental consulting company
based in North Vancouver, B.C., is analyzing the feasibility of
integrating RADARSAT-2 imagery with traditional data sources to better
support and service the aquaculture industry, a market the company
claims is the fastest growing food production sector in the world.
Through its RADARSAT-2 Aquaculture Mapping (RAM) project, a team is
acquiring simulated data to test the ability of the satellite's enhanced
beam modes, selective polarization and quad-pol data to improve
aquaculture facility detection and classification. Andy Dean, a remote
sensing and GIS specialist at Hatfield, is hopeful that his predictions
come true. "RADARSAT-2's higher resolution, its Multi-Look Fine
beam, and its quad-polarization should provide us with superior image
quality to visually interpret individual aquaculture facilities and to
map them," explains Dean. "That will be a substantial advantage to
helping boost people's confidence in radar imagery."
"We also hope the fully polarimetric data will enable us to begin
building a classification database of diverse aquaculture structures
worldwide," he adds.
Intelligence for Intelligence
According to Bohane, enhancing RADARSAT-2 with the 1-meter
Spotlight mode will make the satellite attractive to the
intelligence sector.
"The defense sector is an area that historically has been
dominated by the optical market," he says. "With 1-meter
imagery, we expect RADARSAT-2 data to truly become on par
with the optical offerings. Coupled with the satellite's
other program features, we predict the defense and intel
communities' interest in RADARSAT-2 will spike
considerably."
In 2006, MDA's Geospatial Services signed a RADARSAT-2
contract with an Asian client in the intelligence sector.
"For the defense and intel market it's all about change
detection—monitoring areas of interest," says Tom Hughes,
MDA Geospatial Services' RADARSAT-2 sales director. "With
RADARSAT-2's superior SAR imaging time of 28 minutes and its
1-meter Spotlight mode, we will have the technical capacity
to better serve this market."
InSAR Increases
Change detection applications and the increasing need to
monitor infrastructure has helped strengthen the business
case for interferometric SAR (InSAR). Alessandro Ferretti,
CEO and co-founder of Tele-Rilevamento Europa (www.treuropa.com),
a Milan-based company credited with pioneering the
development of the sophisticated permanent scatterer InSAR (PSInSAR)
technique, reports the company's revenues rose 30 percent in
2006 due to an increased awareness and adoption of InSAR for
geohazards monitoring in Europe. He expects the data
continuity provided by RADARSAT-2, along with its advanced
features, will bring further revenue increases during the
next year.
"The improved
technical features of RADARSAT-2, compared to the RADARSAT-1
sensor, in terms of platform stability, spatial resolution
and polarimetric capabilities will definitely make new InSAR
applications feasible," he says. "For example, the higher
spatial resolution should allow users to monitor individual
buildings in a city and improve the ability to detect tiny
displacements affecting dikes and dams, both of which are
presently a challenge."
MDA's Geospatial Services has been increasing its efforts to
commercialize InSAR's use through several successful
pipeline-monitoring and geohazard-monitoring projects in
Latin and North America, proving that the InSAR technique
can be a viable monitoring mechanism in a variety of
monitoring environments such as pipelines, oil and gas
infrastructures and mines. Based on those successes, a few
clients in Latin America are planning to integrate InSAR
into their operational monitoring business. And the company
has several more InSAR projects lined up in both regions.
In addition, RADARSAT-2 should open new InSAR monitoring
opportunities in areas that have proven problematic for
RADARSAT-1 such as urban environments, according to Adrian
McCardle, a project manager with MDA Geospatial Services.
"The 3-meter and 1-meter
resolutions of RADARSAT-2 will allow users to find smaller
targets to monitor large-scale subsidence of a dense city or
rural setting," relates McCardle. "In rural areas where you
don't have many point targets, the higher spatial resolution
will enable us to better detect scatterers. In urban areas
where you often have too many point targets, we'll be able
to refine our detection down to individual buildings."
CCRS' Singhroy sees strong
potential for RADARSAT-2 and InSAR for monitoring land
motion, particularly along linear assets such as transport
and energy corridors. He and his team are developing
methodologies and guidelines for InSAR applications in
complex terrain for monitoring strategic energy and
transport corridors. He is particularly focused on studying
the feasibility of using InSAR techniques as a remote
monitoring tool for the pending Mackenzie Gas Project, a planned
1,220-kilometer natural gas pipeline network along the Mackenzie Valley
in Canada's Northwest Territories that will connect far northern gas
fields in Canada and the United States.
"Although the pipeline hasn't
been built yet, we are using InSAR motion maps to help the project
managers refine the proposed route around high-risk areas, and we expect
it will be used as a routine monitoring tool to watch these areas," says
Singhroy. "RADARSAT-2's high resolution, its right-left looking and
multi-incidence-angle capabilities will allow users to choose the right
viewing angle for a particular terrain. This will make the satellite
well suited for providing reliable InSAR-motion maps, which will lead to
a substantial commercial impact."
Staying Grounded
As promising as the outlook appears for RADARSAT-2, it's all just
rhetoric if the data never reach users. The satellite's ground
operations are, in many users' minds, equally important to the
capabilities of the spacecraft.
"The satellite technology is a huge driver for us, but equally if not
more important than the sensor capabilities of the technology is the
satellite's ground segment," says Grant Bruce, vice president and
principal at Hatfield. "There are a surprising number of applications
that require data at a certain time and place, and MDA's Geospatial
Services is good at getting the data to you when you need it."
Building on the strength of RADARSAT‑1's ground and operations segment,
RADARSAT‑2 will be operated with notably improved ground segment
hardware and software to support enhanced, streamlined data operations
for satellite tasking, data reception, processing, ordering and
distribution. Philippe Rolland, MDA Geospatial Services' head of
RADARSAT-2 mission planning, says the upgrades were designed to support
the satellite's increased data loads. With 28 minutes of SAR imaging
time and polarimetric data, data volumes will be substantial.
Customers who need fast access to imagery such as defense and emergency
management personnel will benefit from a programming lead time of up to
12 hours for rapid programming and up to three hours for emergency and
urgent acquisitions—four times faster tasking compared to RADARSAT-1.
According to MDA's Geospatial Services literature, processing speeds
have been increased: "Up to eight
typical RADARSAT-2 products will be produced in under 90 minutes from
time of reception." According to Rolland, overall data delivery times
will be cut in half.
Many lessons learned with RADARSAT-1 were applied to improving
RADARSAT-2's ground segment and operational features.
"We designed RADARSAT-2 to provide a much more seamless and responsive
service to customers," explains Rolland. "For example, we'll be able to
begin processing orders for archived data as soon as we receive them,
and customers will be able to track the status of their order in real
time via a Web interface."
A signature of the RADARSAT program has been the
access to MDA's Geospatial Services’ acquisition planners 24 hours a
day, seven days a week. That tradition will continue with RADARSAT-2,
along with extended hours for operational staff in Eastern Canada to
further improve response times.
The ability to offer both the technology and the ground operations to
support it will be a critical component to MDA's Geospatial Services'
commercial success.
"Competitively, everyone wants to have the highest resolution
possible," says Singhroy. "But from a science point of view, 1
meter and 3 meter is mostly academic. If you're resolving a car from a
house, you’ll see both with either resolution. The data provider that
can deliver the imagery when you need it is the one that’ll get the
business. In my opinion, MDA's Geospatial Services has a market niche
because they have 24-hour access to planners, they have the SAR
technology and the data distribution system to deliver data quickly."
Indeed, perhaps the RADARSAT sequel will be better than the original.